It doesn't look traced...so I'd give you a 5/5. It is good to try and draw from what you observe, then move own and draw something on your own.
Comments
8
You copied this from a Blizzard picture. For a copy, i'll give it a 2/5.
need some shadow effects... but its nice. 
I like it if its your 5/5 :]
nice
hm, perhaps. remember, roman legionaires had very long tower shields, why not this soldier having a long shield
yes i made it myself only i think the shield is a bit to long it doesn't seen to be realistic dont you think? 
self-made? if yes, here a 5/5