well, i'm sorry, but i'm not really positive about it. (maybe i'm just spoiled by other great cinematics i've seen..)
Some tips: - music fadein/fadeout when the battle starts. - Grammar - reduce the obviousness in the monologs and dialogs, the text sometimes made me feel like i was watching a pre-school comicserie of some kind. (with that i meant the parts like 'first i will have to take off my armor, and lay down my sword') - Try to use a space, or enter after a sentence is ended. also watch the use of questionmarks, some sentences missed some.
---
@ part 2:
- Who is the warden, where did she come from, why did she attack thranduil? - Omg at the rowboat, that looks terrible, i'd advice you to change that.
Thank you for your honesty,I will try and make my other Lonely sea's cinematics better.I do relize I've made some huge mistakes but do take this in account,I did do both of these cinematics in less then 4 hours.
well, then you can be blamed for nothing but not taking enough time to refine things. For that amount of time, they're really not bad. Try and spend some more time then, i'm sure you can do alot better