Poll: Who Kicks most ass Illidan or Arthas

Kerrigansee? i am the best!!

and psychomagnataur really is right. illidan is so much better than some pathetic human.

EY! yes, Illidan probably is more powerfull, but Arthas is not pathetic! now you made me cry! He is a hero who wants to destroy all good in the name of the Lich King - that is ambition - I say that Illidan is more a tool of Kil'Jaeden, than Arthas is a tool of the Lich King

I hope one day to rule the earth, and then I'm gonna nuke everyone who opposes me, simply bacause you would be worthless in comparison to me, if I was president of the Earth

btw, PsychoMagnataur, that last comment is a really big "but"

Omg... look 1. Arthas and Kerrigan are similar in storyline (Play Starcraft again and play close attention to her story *Good girl defends her planet, good girl is assimulated, planet is assimulated, bla bla bla)

2.Arthas is 1. Not a mumbling duffus 2. Not a tool because he is doing it now because he wants to (Illidan is just filling his shorts when his master shows up though) 3. Yes, has a powerfull sword, why, because his is the choosen of the Lich King to use it (How many people qualify for that job?) 4. WILL KILL ANY MORTAL THAT OPPOSES HIM 5. I can keep going till about number.... hmm.... 37.

@DragonElement - I luv you ^^

HE SAID IT! DON'T ARGUE .... plz ...... someone ..... lock thread?

*Arthas and Illidan were equal in RoC.

I A
1-1

Illidan "consumed" the power of the Skull of Gul'dan and became a strong kickass demon with wings and stuff.

I A
11-1

Arthas injured Illidan badly in the end of the TFT campaign.

I A
11-6

Arthas "fused"(?) together with Ner'zhul and became the new lich king.

I A
11-26

Illidan got some old half dead Draeneis and a band of crazed elves.

I A
16-26

Arthas controls the undead scourge.

I A
16-86

Woo, this is a hot topic!

Arthas + Undead Scourge

Illidan + Draenai + Naga + Blood Elves + Random Demons

Arthas Advantages : Lich King presence, Scourge builds with kills, Uber Runeblade, Kickass undead bug sidekick, Unholy Aura, Healing (D Coil)
Arthas Disadvantages : He is a moron, he attacks WAAAAYY too slow, he is weakened, he begins WAAAAYY outnumbered...

Illidan Advantages : Demonized, 3 races, 3 heros (Illidan, Kael, Vasj), bigger forces
Illidan Disadvantages : He is a moron, no team support abilities, he is blind, he was beaten pretty bad by Night Elves (i.e. Maiev OWNED him, cuz she OWNS everyone)

Alternate ending (as I would have done it)
Illidan and Arthas fight, no body wins. Maiev finds Ilidan and goes to capture him. Anub' Arak goes "Wrooooaaarr" and fights Illidan. Maiev OWNZORS Arthas' ass by shadow strike + avatar + fan o knives, he dies. Illidan kills Anub' Arak. Maiev and Illidan fight. A BIG ASS MAGNATAUR SHOWS UP AND OWNZ EVERYONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!! MUHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Yeah, thats how it [i]should have been...

Illidan, in short, is like every other Demon Hunter out there. He relies on his agility to survive. All he can really do is soak up the attackes like every other high level Demon Hunter (Which is why most pros will tell you to attack a Demon Hunter last, by the way). Arthas is better. Much, much, much, much better. And if he gets lonly he can talk to his sword! You can't beat that!

when i get lonly i talk to jodie, the possessed form of my house

KEEWWWLLL

Kerriganwhen i get lonly i talk to jodie, the possessed form of my house

.... what? WHAT??? What the **** is THAT? Where is Illidan and Arthas in this? Kerrigan, you dimwit, darkhearted, bold, sarcastic yooouuu, YOU!!! NaRGH!

Its definatly Illidan, Illidan is immortal plus hes got lots of allies. An if Kiljaden sees Illidan getting hurt Kiljaden will eat ARTHAS!! ROAR!!!!!

Ok, notice that the new guy wrote that "Illidan was badly injured at the end of TFT". Dude, I think (and know) he's dead.

Illidan isnt dead. all of the nightelves except Illidan gave there immortality to save the tree. (i forget its name) tree of life... or somthing, i dunno.. oh yah, world tree

no - the dreaded Sea-Badger (you are not gonna find it in WE so dont bother) took Illidans immortality, and started to gnaw away at it, like if it was a piece of... cheese

thruth!

I think Illidan is more powerfull and besides i doubt Arthas could really jump that high

There's a difference between immortality and invulnerability.