Poll: Who Kicks most ass Illidan or Arthas

If I remember the warcraft lore right, Illidan didn't die.

Most of the elves died when Arthas attacked Quel'Thalas and played with their pritty little fountain.
The orcs killed allmost all draenei, only one small "tribe".
And I belive the naga abandoned Illidan after the battle between Arthas and him but I'm not sure.
This would make Illidans force fairly small.

While Arthas what? got control over allmost every dead thing in Northrend and Lordaeron or something like that?

Arthas force>Illidans force

And weren't Illidan supposed to destroy the Lich King? Didn't kil'jaeden get angry at him when he failed and went to Outland? So wouldn't kil'jaeden probably be pissed of at Illidan now when he failed again?

kil'jaeden>Illidan

Most of the elves died when Arthas attacked Quel'Thalas and played with their pritty little fountain.

Ah, there's were the plot holes start to appear. Any race you control has only very few warriors.

And I belive the naga abandoned Illidan after the battle between Arthas and him but I'm not sure.

Heh. You'd debate or even lie to protect the fame of your hero, Arthas?

The Naga did not abandon Illidan. Perhaps those few Naga warriors which tried to conquer small parts of Kalimdor confused you?

I'm certain I read somewhere that the the combined forces of the Naga and Blood Elves fled to Outland after their defeat.

While Arthas what? got control over allmost every dead thing in Northrend and Lordaeron or something like that?

Not quite. The Lich King telephatically controls a lot of living entities. The wendigo, for example.
Also, the majority of the Lich King's power has faded, and a lot of his warriors have turned on him.
Strange. Arthas liberated the Lich King by shattering his prison. In this matter, all the Lich King's power should have been lost.

"There's a fracture in my prison, the Frozen Throne, and my energies are seeping from it."
-Ner'zhul

This fracture the Lich King mentioned has enlarged quite a bit.
Yet, the Lich King slowly regains his power… Despite that fact, he completely lost control over the Forsaken.
This is getting confusing…

If Illidan was still alive, I'd say, obviously, that Arthas is more powerful than Illidan…

And weren't Illidan supposed to destroy the Lich King? Didn't kil'jaeden get angry at him when he failed and went to Outland? So wouldn't kil'jaeden probably be pissed of at Illidan now when he failed again?

Certainly. Especially now he killed Maghteridon and conquered Outland.
However, this has absolutely nothing to do with the power of one of those individuals.

Ah, there's were the plot holes start to appear. Any race you control has only very few warriors.

What are you talking about? It might just be my bad english so could you explain?

Heh. You'd debate or even lie to protect the fame of your hero, Arthas?

I'm not lying and I hope I'm not trying to start a debate.
"I belive" "I'm not sure" It's true I do belive the naga went back to the sea but I don't remember my source so I'm not sure.

The Naga did not abandon Illidan. Perhaps those few Naga warriors which tried to conquer small parts of Kalimdor confused you?

I'm certain I read somewhere that the the combined forces of the Naga and Blood Elves fled to Outland after their defeat.

I'm certain I read somewhere that the naga didn't flee to Outland.

Not quite. The Lich King telephatically controls a lot of living entities. The wendigo, for example.
Also, the majority of the Lich King's power has faded, and a lot of his warriors have turned on him.
Strange. Arthas liberated the Lich King by shattering his prison. In this matter, all the Lich King's power should have been lost.

"There's a fracture in my prison, the Frozen Throne, and my energies are seeping from it."
-Ner'zhul

This fracture the Lich King mentioned has enlarged quite a bit.
Yet, the Lich King slowly regains his power… Despite that fact, he completely lost control over the Forsaken.
This is getting confusing…

If Illidan was still alive, I'd say, obviously, that Arthas is more powerful than Illidan…

Yeah... I forgot about that.

I would say: Arthas kicks Illidans ass but Illidan will allways be the sexiest.

on one hand u have ner'zul+arthas

well on the other u have illidan+Gul'Dan

in my opinion arthas and ner'zul=strength

and illidan and gul'dan = night elf speed and orc speels and intelegence

sure ner'zul was the first orc to drink the dmeon blood but he was also the first to fall victum to it that makes hima pussy/grom hellscream even over came the dmeons blood

and the lich kings is nothing i mean come on hes armor...ina big ice chunk

Illidan here my friend..........now just to get him some better blades...i mean his new ones r nothing compared to his ld ones with the monkey face in the center

Also you all act as if illidans dead...i think a mighty warrior who was caged for 10 thousand years and has also been training that long can withstand a little blade slice...........

COME ON HES ILLIDAN

illidan owns arthas ne day

and btw: dont say illidan got cought by maive

shes a fucking detumened bitch and she even leave her own poeple behind to get him...its not like arthas has troble sleeping at night with some wench fallowing him weere ever he goes -.-

well on the other u have illidan+Gul'Dan

Gul'dan never fought at Illidan's side, but Illidan consumed what was left of his power.

Kil'jaeden supports Illidan just as Ner'zhul supports Arthas.

We're discussing here about the strenght and courage of these two individuals, Illidan and Arthas. Not about the forces they control.

and the lich kings is nothing i mean come on hes armor...ina big ice chunk

Nothing but an extremely powerful and telepathic incorporeal being, whose mental energy is enormous.

there both equal, arthas is kickass b/c he gets Frostmourne, Illidan is kickass b/c he is just cooler than arthas, in the terms of your poll, THEY BOTH KICK ASS!!!!!

but hey i would own both arthas and illidan, cuz i have invunerablity with the 7 chaos emeralds and 7 master emeralds combined makes me...

HYPER-SUPER FINAL_FANTASIES-7!!!! MUAHAHAHHAHA

if yall dont know what that is, read sonic comics super special #20, Hyper Knuckles vs Super Sonic

master emeralds make you go Hyper, chaos emeralds make you go Super

Arthas with his kick-ass sword. Hoping Illidan will burn in hell =)

Go Go Go Lich King !

hmm

Illidan isnt dead he is alive to yet some of you know it said Illidan used what strength he could to escape to outland after arthas left to go to the throne.

I personally like illidan becuase he is a nightelf/demon and he is pretty cool a ancient magic user/swordsman and has my favorite races naga and high=blood elves.

yea, ilidan only was kept allive through the skull of guldan, so..., with what he could do he escaped to outland, awaiting for kil'jedan to kick his ass

well

Kil'Jaeden is actuelly hiding himself somewhere just a guess its Netherland*lol* from Arthas.

no kil' jeadan is ruler of outand, so he would hide there

um

wouldnt it be better if he hid in his own demonic world?

.....this is supposed to be in caps but i dont need a one week ban....

OUTLAND is his own WORLD god

-_-;

Actually, Kil'jaeden doesn't really rule any worlds...he's just commanding the Burning Legion until Blizzard decides it's time for Sargeras to come back. Illidan just took over Outland because he was looking for a hiding place. He's now there along with his followers.(B-Elves, Naga, Dranei)

And for anyone thinking the Naga didn't go to Outland...what were those fish-like humanoids there in those Outland missions? Orcs?